OMG A DD I woke up today so confused at all the messages, but holy crap! I never expected this. ;w; Thank you all so much for the favs and the comments! I have lots more tutorials for polymer clay, so please check them out if you're interested in learning: [link]
This is my first DD. *sniff* I never thought the day would come. ;__; Thank you =PirateLotus-Stock for suggesting and ^shelldevil for featuring!!
You could use makeup. When I first started polymer clay I used a cheap palette of makeup I got at the dollar store for a dollar or two. The only inconvenience is that makeup has that glittery kinda glare to it.
Any colored chalk (even sidewalk chalk? xD ) would work, I think. But chalk pastels are really inexpensive and come in sets with lots of colors, so it's worth buying some.